A Quick Question Regarding Parameters

I could swear if I have a procedure with an out parameter, of a by-copy or by-reference type, that assignments to that parameter will take effect even if the procedure raises an exception immediately thereafter. However, I scanned through the ARM and was unable to find the section guaranteeing me this. I was recently reviewing controlled types again, and relearned that Finalize is called even when Initialize raises an exception. A library that I’ve written has a subtle flaw unless this out parameter assignment quality holds. Any guidance on the relevant part of the ARM would be appreciated.

The copy back of an [ in ] out mode parameter of a by-copy type only occurs on normal return from the subprogram [ARM 6.4.1(17)]. If the subprogram propagates an exception, the copy back does not occur, and the variable retains its original value. Both GNAT 12.3.0 and ObjectAda 10.5U5 behave this way.

Darn. I guess I’ll give the one component the controlled type has a default value, which should fix the problem, if I’m reading the ARM correctly. I very much appreciate the help.

I’m getting some odd results. The code in question can be found here: http://verisimilitudes.net/2022-08-22

The Initialize procedure calls socket and bind, raising an exception if either fails; the Finalize procedure simply calls close. However, I decided to use strace to see what happens when this fails; since I didn’t originally give a default value to the Socket_Nonsense component of the controlled type, I thought close would be called on a random file descriptor, and wanted to doublecheck this, but I’m not seeing close called at all.

Have I misunderstood something regarding controlled types? I’m a little confused right now.

I suppose I misread 7.6.1 14.a of the ARM:

Ramification: It is not a bounded error for Initialize to propagate an exception. If Initialize propagates an exception, then no further calls on Initialize are performed, and those components that have already been initialized (either explicitly or by default) are finalized in the usual way.

So, here I was thinking that I had a subtle and very rare uninitialized variable use, because it’s possible for Initialize to leave the file descriptor untouched, and I thought that Finalize would still be called, but this is wrong. Instead, Finalize will only be called for recursive such initialized components. So, I didn’t write an uninitialized variable use flaw, but the Initialize procedure I wrote does need to clean up after itself. I accidentally wrote a little resource leak.

Well, don’t I feel silly. Once again, I appreciate the help.

Alexis Ada Reference Manual

  • Legal Information
  • Contact Alexis

Home

GNAT Errors

Below is a list of GNAT errors and how to resolve the problem. Whenever appropriate we show a code example of what generates the error and what can be done to resolve it. At times, we point you to a specific source file in the compiler since those show you the perfect example of how a working version.

GNAT Error Last change on
2011/02/02
2011/02/01
2011/12/28
2011/12/28
2011/02/21
2011/02/06
2011/12/27
2011/12/28
2011/02/04
2011/02/01
2011/12/28
2011/02/23
2011/03/14
2011/02/04
2011/02/06
2011/12/28
2011/12/28
2011/03/14
2011/12/28
2011/02/05
2011/02/05
2011/02/04
2011/02/01
2011/12/27
2011/02/02
2011/02/01
2011/02/01
2011/02/04
2011/12/28
2012/01/12
2011/02/14
2011/02/12

Another excellent resource about Ada is the Ada FAQ on the faqs website: Ada FAQ: Programming with Ada (part 1 of 4) .

Powered by Made to Order Software Corp.

Latest Edits

  • 3.6 Array Types
  • 3.5.5 Operations of Discrete Types
  • 3.5.9 Fixed Point Types
  • Section 7: Packages
  • Introduction

External References

  • Annotated Ada 2005 Reference Manual
  • ACATS 3.0 User's Guide
  • Ada 2005 Tests
  • Annotated Ada 2012 Reference Manual
  • Ada 95 Reference Manual
  • Ada Advantages
  • ARA Community

Copyright ©1986 owned by the United States Government. All rights reserved. Direct inquiries to the Ada Information Clearinghouse at [email protected] .

ModeNatureRights
ModeRequirement

ada assignment to in mode parameter not allowed

ada assignment to in mode parameter not allowed essay about school assembly ada assignment to in mode parameter not allowed site to zone assignment list preference wikipedia single assignment dissertation binding leeds who invented homework for students doing homework gif sentence homework year 5 ada assignment to in mode parameter not allowed essay about uzbekistan newspaper dissertation binding service lincoln home workout like curves essayer yosemite problem solution essay about drug abuse ada assignment to in mode parameter not allowed essayer translation do you think homework is necessary essay doctor napier literature review in research paper pdf essay computer make life easier dissertation droit plan apparent introduction dissertation en francais ada assignment to in mode parameter not allowed myself essay ppt research papers advertising and consumerism essay on how to keep your country clean user rights assignment gpo essay on stress on college students essay on why smoking is bad for your health essay picnic spot research paper xml argumentative essay on volunteering essays college life essay about conceptual art dodea homework policy role mass media essay ppt lord of the flies island description web based assignment submission system ada assignment to in mode parameter not allowed love essay to him british library dissertation search homework help geography science aspects 3 homework book answers homework now teacher login ada assignment to in mode parameter not allowed junior essay on child labour research paper new media essay on rural and urban poverty essay on character is more important than money dissertation proposal guidance essay holiday to malacca dissertation nature et culture ada assignment to in mode parameter not allowed nursing essays online uk essay on crime in youth young goodman brown essay barbri new york essay advantage assignment about ecosystem homework hotline canada research paper about kpop essay volleyball passion construction finance management assignment nicmar barbie homework games mba essays harvard glogster book review assignment essay about a time when you helped someone the homework never ends lyrics essay on goa environment

Share this:

Leave a comment cancel reply.

' src=

  • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
  • Subscribe Subscribed
  • Copy shortlink
  • Report this content
  • View post in Reader
  • Manage subscriptions
  • Collapse this bar
  • Stack Overflow for Teams Where developers & technologists share private knowledge with coworkers
  • Advertising & Talent Reach devs & technologists worldwide about your product, service or employer brand
  • OverflowAI GenAI features for Teams
  • OverflowAPI Train & fine-tune LLMs
  • Labs The future of collective knowledge sharing
  • About the company Visit the blog

Collectives™ on Stack Overflow

Find centralized, trusted content and collaborate around the technologies you use most.

Q&A for work

Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search.

Get early access and see previews of new features.

How to remove 'Assignment of Parameter 'variable' is not allowed'

I'm programming a Controller using Java and I'm checking the style using Sonar. In my Sonar I have an error that says:

'Assignment of Parameter 'variable' is not allowed.

The line that it's on is:

So I'm wondering how I could get that error off since I can't just create a setter when I'm using that annotation.

I'm using Eclipse . The rule being broke is Parameter Assignment .

Drew Kennedy's user avatar

  • 1 Can we see more context? Aka more code? –  Adam Commented Jul 8, 2015 at 17:38
  • are you using eclipse? –  Karthik Commented Jul 8, 2015 at 18:25
  • Please post more code. –  systemhalted Commented Jul 9, 2015 at 0:53
  • Can you post which rule is raising the issue ? (rule key) –  benzonico Commented Jul 9, 2015 at 6:49

In your if condition block, you are setting variable to null and it happens to be your method parameter. Instead of assigning the value to the method parameter, create a local variable and use it and return the value of the local variable from the method if at all it is intended.

systemhalted's user avatar

Your Answer

Reminder: Answers generated by artificial intelligence tools are not allowed on Stack Overflow. Learn more

Sign up or log in

Post as a guest.

Required, but never shown

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy .

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged java sonarqube or ask your own question .

  • Featured on Meta
  • Announcing a change to the data-dump process
  • We've made changes to our Terms of Service & Privacy Policy - July 2024

Hot Network Questions

  • Is it possible to use "sshd_config" to prevent root login only after a user has logged in via ssh?
  • What do you call the number appearing on the front of a bus?
  • How do I know when I have sufficiently mastered a right hand speed drill for accordion?
  • Change score as predictor
  • Is it safe to keep an outdated credit card?
  • Parsing vivado reports
  • In an expanding universe could black hole pairs keep orbiting each other forever?
  • Is there any family history for Klaus Stortebeker?
  • Do strawberry seeds have different DNA within the same fruit?
  • What is the color of the final disc(s)?
  • How to make an operator form of Part[] to use with // (Postfix)
  • Are there non-religious variants of moral realism that defend the existence of objectively evil thoughts, intentions, and desires?
  • Does spring stop applying force as soon as we cut it?
  • How is the name "Took" pronounced?
  • Thomson's lamp: a useless paradox?
  • Are there any signs that the laptop fan is broken during use?
  • What is so fundamental about polynomial functions that they are used to demarcate the Hardness boundary in NP complexity classes?
  • Xichang is a spaceport
  • Foundations and contradictions of Scholze's work: the category of presentable infinity categories contains itself
  • The existence of an eigenvalue of a finite-dim matrix, in a vector space over an arbitrary field.
  • How does the grammar in 这不关你的事 work?
  • Washed my passport by mistake, can that cause a problem?
  • Wife missing in Italy
  • Why does modified z-score not pick up an obvious outlier?

ada assignment to in mode parameter not allowed

IMAGES

  1. Parameter settings of the ADA algorithm for the indicated method

    ada assignment to in mode parameter not allowed

  2. PPT

    ada assignment to in mode parameter not allowed

  3. 4. ADAT AND SMALL ADA OVERVIEW

    ada assignment to in mode parameter not allowed

  4. Cheat sheet for the mode parameter of open() : r/Python

    ada assignment to in mode parameter not allowed

  5. 1. 30pts What is the output of the following Ada-like

    ada assignment to in mode parameter not allowed

  6. PL/SQL Tutorial #58: Lab for Parameter Mode (IN, OUT, IN OUT) in PL/SQL @OracleShooter

    ada assignment to in mode parameter not allowed

VIDEO

  1. DELTA SERVO DRIVE PARAMETERS UPLOAD & DOWNLOAD || ASD-A2 PROGRAM UPLOAD & DOWNLOAD || ECAM UPLOAD

  2. Delta MS300 Drive Wiring!Delta Drive Reverse Forward Wiring!Delta Drive Parameter Setting

  3. Analysis and Design of Algorithms

  4. What if RESIDENT EVIL 4 Remake Assignment Ada

  5. ADA_UNIT 5: Assignment Problem with Branch and Bound Method -Swetha Goudar

  6. June 2024 Assignment Submission की New Guidelines आ गई हैं!

COMMENTS

  1. Assignment to "in" mode parameter not allowed

    This is by design. A formal parameter of mode in is a constant view; it cannot be updated within the subprogram body. A constant cannot be the target of an assignment operation. See section 3.3 od Ada Reference Manual, paragraphs 13, 15, 17 and 25 in particular.

  2. ada

    test_update.adb:11:09: error: assignment to "in" mode parameter not allowed test_update.adb:28:59: error: unexpected argument for "Access" attribute When I use the code in the comments, and remove the second parameter for the function, it still doesn't work.

  3. assignment to "in" mode parameter not allowed

    2. You cannot assign a read-only variable. When you learn about Ada, you are taught that parameters are passed as copy when you are using the in keyword. The fact is that the compiler can decide to pass the parameter by reference and therefore it views the variable as a read-only variable. You cannot write in that variable.

  4. A Quick Question Regarding Parameters

    The copy back of an [in] out mode parameter of a by-copy type only occurs on normal return from the subprogram [ARM 6.4.1(17)]. If the subprogram propagates an exception, the copy back does not occur, and the variable retains its original value. Both GNAT 12.3.0 and ObjectAda 10.5U5 behave this way.

  5. 6.2 Formal Parameter Modes

    1. [A parameter_specification declares a formal parameter of mode in, in out, or out .] Static Semantics. 2. A parameter is passed either by copy or by reference. [When a parameter is passed by copy, the formal parameter denotes a separate object from the actual parameter, and any information transfer between the two occurs only before and ...

  6. 6.2 Formal Parameter Modes

    A parameter of a by-copy type is passed by copy, unless the formal parameter is explicitly aliased. 4. A type is a by-reference type if it is a descendant of one of the following: 5. a tagged type; 6. a task or protected type; 7/3. { AI05-0096-1 } an explicitly limited record typea nonprivate type with the reserved word limited in its declaration;

  7. 12.4 Formal Objects

    A generic formal object of mode in is like a constant initialized to the value of the explicit_generic_actual_parameter. 1.b. ... Mode out is not allowed for generic formal objects. 7. ... (The part about denoting a variable, and renaming being allowed, is most certainly not a Name Resolution Rule.) 8/2

  8. Formal Parameter Modes

    2. A parameter is passed either by copy or by reference. When a parameter is passed by copy, the formal parameter denotes a separate object from the actual parameter, and any information transfer between the two occurs only before and after executing the subprogram. When a parameter is passed by reference, the formal parameter denotes (a view ...

  9. GNAT Errors

    assignment to "in" mode parameter not allowed: 2011/02/02 : attribute "unchecked_access" cannot be applied to a subprogram: 2011/02/01 "end loop;" expected for "loop" at line <number> ... Another excellent resource about Ada is the Ada FAQ on the faqs website: Ada FAQ: Programming with Ada (part 1 of 4). Latest Edits. 3.6 Array Types.

  10. 5.2 Parameter Lists

    By showing the mode of parameters, you aid the reader. If you do not specify a parameter mode, the default mode is in. Explicitly showing the mode indication of all parameters is a more assertive action than simply taking the default mode. Anyone reviewing the code later will be more confident that you intended the parameter mode to be in. Use ...

  11. The use of IN OUT in Ada

    23. An in parameter can be read but not written by the subprogram. in is the default. Prior to Ada 2012, functions were only allowed to have in parameters. The actual parameter is an expression. An out parameter implies that the previous value is of no interest. The subprogram is expected to write to the parameter.

  12. Ada Reference Manual

    54 Assignment to a discriminant of an object (after its initialization) is not allowed, since the name of a discriminant is a constant; neither assignment_statement s nor assignments inherent in passing as an in out or out parameter are allowed. Note however that the value of a discriminant can be changed by assigning to the enclosing object ...

  13. 6.2 Formal Parameter Modes

    NOTE 1 { AI12-0056-1 } The mode of a formal parameter describes the direction of information transfer to or from the subprogram_body (see 6.1 ). NOTE 2 A formal parameter of mode in is a constant view (see 3.3 ); it cannot be updated within the subprogram_body.

  14. Parameter Associations

    Name Resolution Rules. 2. The formal_parameter_ selector_name of a parameter_association shall resolve to denote a parameter_specification of the view being called. 3. {actual parameter (for a formal parameter)} The actual parameter is either the explicit_actual_parameter given in a parameter_association for a given formal parameter, or the ...

  15. Ada '83 Rationale, Sec 8.2: Parameter Modes

    Such reading and updating rights are specified by the mode of the formal parameter. Three parameter modes are provided in Ada: they are the modes in, in out, and out. The properties of formal parameters of each of these modes are summarized in the table given below. The second column indicates the nature of the formal parameter: constant or ...

  16. In mode parameter in an assignment statement

    I thought it should be rejected during compilation because in mode parameter is not allowed in an assignment statement. But, it was compiled successfully under GNAT obviously. ... parameter is not allowed in an assignment statement. But, it was compiled successfully under GNAT obviously. ... That Ada access types allow for implicit dereference ...

  17. 4.2 Subprogram parameters

    The main topic here is the fact that functions (but not operators) in Ada 2012 can have parameters of any mode. This is a topic left over from Ada 2005. The epilogue to the Rationale for Ada 2005 ... Calls to value returning procedures are only allowed in assignment statements, initializations and procedure calls. ...

  18. ada assignment to in mode parameter not allowed

    ada assignment to in mode parameter not allowed essay about school assembly ada assignment to in mode parameter not allowed site to zone assignment list preference wikipedia single assignment dissertation binding leeds who invented homework for students doing homework gif sentence homework year 5 ada assignment to in mode parameter not allowed essay about uzbekistan…

  19. 5.2 Assignment Statements

    Syntax. 2. assignment_statement ::=. variable_ name := expression; 3. The execution of an assignment_statement includes the evaluation of the expression and the assignment of the value of the expression into the target. [An assignment operation (as opposed to an assignment_statement) is performed in other contexts as well, including object ...

  20. How to remove 'Assignment of Parameter 'variable' is not allowed'

    In your if condition block, you are setting variable to null and it happens to be your method parameter. Instead of assigning the value to the method parameter, create a local variable and use it and return the value of the local variable from the method if at all it is intended.